Share This Page

Get An Insurance Quote

Send A Message

Full Name:
Email Address:
Phone Number:
Questions or Comments :

Individual Insurance Carriers


Easy Insurance Enrollment and Rate Comparisons

Hart, McConahey, & Martz Insurance of Erie, PA provides individual products options that individuals want and value today. Our programs are easy to enroll in or apply for and offer administrative solutions for the employer. How we serve you is as important as what we provide. First, we listen to you. We discuss your needs and answer your questions. Next, we look at both your short-term and long-term objectives and help put your insurance needs in perspective. Finally, when you are comfortable with the program we develop for you, it is implemented with state-of-the-art technology. We not only provide automated record keeping, but also a computerized system that permits rate comparisons among leading insurance companies nationwide. 

Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield - Health

As one of the leading health insurers in Pennsylvania, Highmark's mission is to provide access to affordable, quality health care enabling individuals to live longer, healthier lives. Based in Pittsburgh, Highmark serves 4.6 million people through the company's health care benefits business. Highmark contributes millions of dollars to help keep quality health care programs affordable and to support community-based programs that work to improve people's health.

UPMC Health Plan - Health

UPMC Health Plan is owned by the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC), one of the nation's top-ranked health systems. As part of an integrated health care delivery system, UPMC Health Plan partners with UPMC and community network providers to improve clinical outcomes as well as the health of the greater community.

Health America - Health

HealthAmerica and HealthAssurance* are leaders in providing innovative health benefit solutions to companies in Pennsylvania and Ohio. We are headquartered in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with offices located in Pittsburgh, State College, Plymouth Meeting, Lancaster, and Erie, Pennsylvania.

Aetna - Health

Aetna is one of the nation's leading diversified health care benefits companies, serving members with information and resources to help them make better informed decisions about their health care.

Golden Rule - Health

If you’re having a hard time finding coverage that meets your needs, compare the advantages of UnitedHealthOneSM health plans, underwritten by Golden Rule Insurance Company. We make it easy to match your circumstances with plan benefits and monthly premiums. Get a quote in less than 30 seconds.

UnitedHealthcare One - Health

UnitedHealthcare is an operating division of UnitedHealth Group, the largest single health carrier in the United States.

UnitedHealthcare Medicare Solutions

United Healthcare Medicare Solutions are leaders in providing health benefit solutions to beneficiaries in Pennsylvania and Ohio.


A divison of CVS Health offering competitive Prescription coverage to Medicare Clients.


Providing Medicare Part D Products to the PA Market.

Genworth Financial - Life

Genworth Financial helps millions of people around the world achieve their dreams—of homeownership, financial independence, a comfortable retirement and protection for their loved ones. We’re a global financial security company dedicated to providing confidence and financial peace of mind today, while helping protect against life’s uncertainties.

New Era - Life

New Era provides affordable insurance solutions that help you take control of your financial and health care future. Our quality products are backed by a commitment to keeping your insurance premiums stable and as low as possible. We are also devoted to superior customer service. When you call us, you will talk to a live person… a person who cares about helping you and your family.

AIG - Life

American International Group, Inc. (AIG), a world leader in insurance and financial services, is the leading international insurance organization with operations in more than 130 countries and jurisdictions. AIG companies serve commercial, institutional and individual customers through the most extensive worldwide property-casualty and life insurance networks of any insurer. In addition, AIG companies are leading providers of retirement services, financial services and asset management around the world. AIG's common stock is listed on the New York Stock Exchange, as well as the stock exchanges in Ireland and Tokyo.

John Hancock - Life

At John Hancock, we offer a comprehensive portfolio of life insurance products that have been designed to be extremely competitive and provide real value. Whether you are looking for guaranteed death benefit protection, low-cost coverage or consistently strong cash value accumulation potential, John Hancock has a product to meet your needs!

Banner Life Insurance - Life

Banner's life insurance products are sold through independent life brokerage agencies in 48 states and the District of Columbia. At Banner Life, we take our financial promises seriously. We also promise to treat our customers fairly and to apply ethical standards to every business transaction. We believe in offering low-cost, innovative products and responsive service. Our goal is to build lasting, mutually beneficial partnerships.

Lincoln Financial Group - Life

Headquartered in the Philadelphia region, Lincoln Financial Group is a Fortune 500 company offering a diverse range of financial services and solutions. With a strong focus on four core business areas — life insurance, annuities, retirement plan services, and group protection — our business is built around supporting, preserving, and enhancing our customer's lifestyles and providing better retirement outcomes.

Sun Life Financial - Life

We offer a range of individual life insurance and group life insurance solutions. So you can protect your family’s quality of life no matter what the future brings, and save your loved ones the stress of financial worries during an already stressful time.

Metlife - Life

MetLife, Inc. is a leading global provider of insurance, annuities and employee benefit programs, serving 90 million customers.

USAble Life Insurance

At USAble Life, we are in the business of providing security for you and your loved ones in the event something unexpected should occur. With a combination of a robust benefits roster and convenient, streamlined customer relations, we are here to serve you as efficiently as possible.

Principal Financial Group

The Principal Financial Group® (The Principal®) is a leading global financial company offering businesses, individuals and institutional clients a wide range of financial products and services. Our range of products and services includes retirement solutions, insurance, wellness programs, and investment and banking products through our diverse family of financial services companies and national network of financial professionals.

Foremost Insurance Group

Foremost is the nation's leading specialty insurer. The difference - we specialize. That sets our policies apart and makes the difference for you and the coverage you receive.

Safeco Insurance

Safeco Insurance, our independent agents help you plan for whatever life may bring - a new house or car, or bigger family. They're also there for you when the unexpected happens, like a fender-bender or a tree crashing through the roof. With Safeco, you get high-quality coverage, sensible advice and a helping hand.

Hagerty Auto Insurance

We specialize in collector and classic car insurance. Our policy is customized to the unique needs of collector vehicle owners and offers better coverage than a standard auto policy.


More than 10 million people choose Progressive to insure their vehicles, making us one of the largest auto insurance groups in the country. Our customers choose us for the value and service we offer, including choices that make your insurance experience convenient, efficient and easy.

Travelers Insurance - Property/Casualty

Travelers offers a wide variety of property and casualty insurance and surety products and services to businesses, organizations and individuals in the United States and in selected international markets. In addition, the company can meet insurance needs in more than 90 countries worldwide through our network of insurers. Products are distributed primarily through independent insurance agents and brokers. Our success is built upon our ability to provide innovative insurance and risk protection products and services in-synch with our customers' needs.

Donegal Insurance Group - Property/Casualty

The Donegal Insurance Group consists of Donegal Mutual Insurance Company, Atlantic States Insurance Company, Southern Insurance Company of Virginia, Le Mars Insurance Company, The Peninsula Insurance Company and Peninsula Indemnity Company. We are proud of our heritage, spanning more than 100 years in the insurance business.

Mutual Benefit - Property/Casualty

A regional property and casualty insurance firm with home offices in Huntingdon, Pennsylvania, Mutual Benefit Group includes five member companies that share a rich and unique tradition within the American insurance industry. MBG offers its insurance coverage through member companies Mutual Benefit Insurance Company and Select Risk Insurance Company. Founded more than 95 years ago as a two-man operation, MBG has grown to employ over 200 people, building a reputation for providing service with a friendly, personal touch.

Hartford Insurance - Property/Casualty

The Hartford is a leading provider of investment products – annuities, mutual funds, college savings plans – as well as life insurance, group and employee benefits, automobile and homeowners' insurance, and business insurance.

Lebanon Valley - Property/Casualty

Lebanon Valley Insurance Company has been meeting the insurance needs of businesses and individuals in Pennsylvania since 1856.

Farmers Fire - Property/Casualty

The Farmers Insurance Group of Companies was built to last, with a firm foundation of reliable businesses and a dedication to continual improvement. What began as a simple Auto insurance company for Farmers has become a multi-line, multi-company insurer and financial services organization with a solid reputation for doing the right thing for the right reason.

Ohio Casualty - Property/Casualty

Ohio Casualty is part of Liberty Mutual Agency Markets, a business unit of Liberty Mutual Group. Agency Markets consists of property & casualty, & specialty insurance carriers that distribute their products & services primarily through independent agents & brokers.

Brethren Mutual Insurance Company

Established in 1897, Brethren Mutual is committed to providing value, quality in insurance protection, reliable service and financial integrity. We offer property-casualty insurance coverage in Maryland, Pennsylvania and Virginia. Brethren Mutual is the largest farm insurance writer in the state of Maryland.

Keystone National Insurance Company

Keystone National Insurance Company may be one of the new kids on the block, commencing business on January 1, 2005, but its parentage goes back some three decades to the Northumberland region in central Pennsylvania. The Keystone Insurers Group, Inc., was born when four agencies joined forces in 1983, protecting people, their families and businesses over that span as it continues to expand coverage throughout the country.

Tuscarora Wayne Insurance Company

A partnership between agents and underwriters is essentially the fuel that powers Tuscarora Wayne Insurance Company (TW), incorporated in 1874.

TW’s success formula is startling in its simplicity, relying on the personalized relationships between independent agents and in-house underwriters. This approach was highlighted by Best’s Review, one of the insurance industry’s premier magazines, in a 2003 article stating that TW underwriters are the wheels that move this business. In fact, Jay W. Chadwick, Chairman/President/Chief Executive Officer, credits “disciplined underwriting” and “easier access to decision-making” for TW’s clients as its leading strengths.

AEGIS Security Insurance Company

Aegis Security Insurance Company is an “A- (excellent)” rated insurer by A.M. Best (Financial Size VII) and is licensed in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. Our principal focus is specialty Property and Casualty insurance, Surety and Accident and Health insurance. We distribute our products through a nationwide network of independent agencies.


Horizontal line
(814)455-0987 | Fax: (814)456-9680 | 2562 West 12th st, suite 250, Erie PA 16505
2022 © Hart, McConahy, & Martz, Inc.
Powered By Epic Web Studios