Share This Page

Get An Insurance Quote

Send A Message

Full Name:
Email Address:
Phone Number:
Questions or Comments :

Meet Our Qualified Staff of Insurance Agents 

At Hart, McConahy & Martz, Insurance we offer personal service from our qualified agents and service representatives no matter what your insurance needs are. Our staff is committed to providing the right coverage to our clients and staying up to date on industry standards. 

R. Carl Martz, RHU

P: 814.455.0987 ext. 106 • F: 814.456.9680

An Erie native, Carl started out in the insurance in 1974, as an agent.  He then taught at an advanced sales school, and eventually became district sales manager for Mutual of Omaha’s western Pennsylvania branch, based in Pittsburgh.  During this time Carl earned his Registered Health Underwriter designation, or RHU. Carl joined Hart, McConahy, & Martz in 1994, and was made partner in 1996.  Carl's first 2 years with the agency were highlighted with over $1,000,000 of new business each year. At the agency, Carl manages the commercial property and casualty department, the employee benefits, and life/health departments. Outside of work, Carl enjoys spending time with his family, boating, fishing, hunting, and skiing.  LINKEDIN profile.


Patrick R. Hart

P: 814.455.0987 • F: 814.456.9680

Born in Erie, Patrick graduated Fairview High School before attending West Virginia University. He first started working at Erie Insurance in 1989 before joining Hart, McConahy, & Martz in 1992, eventually becoming a partner four years later. When he’s not at work, Patrick enjoys hunting, cycling, skiing, and being with his family. LINKEDIN Profile.


Benjamin W. Martz, CPIA

P: 814.455.0987 ext. 119 • F: 814.456.9680

A lifelong resident of Edinboro, Benjamin joined Hart, McConahy, & Martz in June of 2009,and he earned the CPIA (Certified Professional Insurance Advisor) designation in 2013.  Ben was named Partner in January 2015.  Before his time at Hart, McConahy, & Martz, Benjamin graduated from General McLane High School and earned a bachelor’s degree in business management and a minor in marketing from Penn State University. A third generation insurance broker, Benjamin is licensed to sell all lines of insurance, while assisting both individual and commercial clients. Ben has also started a duck decoy manufacturing company in 2010, Lake Effect Decoy.  When he’s not lightening up the mood at the office with his outgoing nature, Benjamin enjoys waterfowl hunting, archery hunting, boating, fishing, snowboarding, sitting on 4 chapter committees for Ducks Unlimited, as well as the Pennsylvania State Council of Ducks Unlimited. Ben Holds Property & Casualty, and Life & Health Licenses in PA, OH, and NY.  LINKEDIN Profile


Kenneth Antalek

Senior Market
P: 814.455.0987 • F: 814.456.9680

Kenneth grew up in Erie, staying in town to earn his bachelor’s degree at Mercyhurst University. Of his over 25 years of experience, the last seven have been with Hart, McConahy, and Martz. When he’s not working, Kenneth likes to golf, play tennis, and go running.


Thomas R. Anderson

Account Executive
P: 814.455.0987 ext. 105 • F: 814.456.9680

Thomas grew up several hours away in Ridgway, Pa., before coming to Erie. Over the years, he has worked The PMA Group, Johnson & Higgins, and Amerisafe Inc., before joining Hart, McConahy, & Martz eight years ago. When out of the office, Thomas enjoys music, antique cars, working with wood, reading, and spending time with his family. LINKEDIN Profile


Gail Sitler

Employee Benefits Coordinator
P: 814.455.0987 ext. 103 • F: 814.456.9680

Hailing from Westfield, NY, Gail has worked in the customer service business for over 20 years. After working for Highmark BCBS, Gail brought her knowledge of health benefits to the Hart, McConahy, & Martz team eight years ago. In her spare time, Gail likes to watch the Erie Seawolves, the Erie Otters, and the Buffalo Bills, as well as reading a good book, curling up by the fire, breakfasts out with her friends, and being with her family. LinkedIn Profile


Pamela Lindberg, CISR

Personal and Commercial Lines Specialist
P: 814-455-0987 ext. 116

An Erie native, Pamela first started in the insurance industry back in 1975, eventually joining the Hart, McConahy, & Martz team 13 years ago. Pam is a very knowledgeable Customer Service Agent. LinkedIn Profile


Mara Allison

Personal Line Specialist
P: (814) 455-0987 x 113 • F: (814) 456-9680
Mara was born and raised in Erie; Mara graduated from Fairview High School before attending Edinboro University. She first started working at Northshore Insurance before joining Hart McConahy & Martz in 2022. Mara holds a Property and Casualty license in PA. When she’s not in the office, Mara enjoys reading, crocheting, skiing, hiking and spending time with family and friends.

Megan Smith

Personal Line Specialist
P: (814) 455-0987 x 114 • F: (814) 456-9680
Megan was born and raised in Northeast Ohio. Megan graduated from Riverside High School, leading her to obtain an associate degree in Business Management from Edinboro University in 2012. She joined the Hart McConahy & Martz team in 2022 after 10 years as a PA Notary. When Megan is not working, she enjoys spending time with her family and friends, being a foster mom for a local shelter, camping and being in the garden.

Darcy Wagner

Personal & Commercial Line Specialist
P: (814) 455-0987 x 127 • F: (814) 456-9680
Darcy joined Hart, McConahy & Martz in 2021. She holds a Pennsylvania Property & Casualty License. Initially Darcy mastered personal lines but wanted the additional challenge of commercial lines. She has risen to the challenge, and now runs the Commercial Team. Outside of work, Darcy enjoys working with draft horses, taking care of her cat "Catnip", and her very special fur niece Lucy.

Cathy Zboyovski

P: 814.455.0987 • F: 814.456.9680

Cathy is a lifelong resident of Erie. She has been employed with Hart, McConahy, & Martz for one year as a part-time resident receptionist. Prior to joining the agency, Cathy worked at Citizens Bank and its predecessor banks for 35 years. Outside of work, Cathy enjoys gardening, yoga, and getting together with friends and family.


Horizontal line
(814)455-0987 | Fax: (814)456-9680 | 2562 West 12th st, suite 250, Erie PA 16505
2022 © Hart, McConahy, & Martz, Inc.
Powered By Epic Web Studios